63
Cecilia
Simon & Garfunkel
1970
The safe pick here was going to be Mrs. Robinson. It's certainly their best song, and if we were doing just a "best song" list that would certainly be a contender. There could certainly be other contenders as well. Shoutout to my friend Joe S. -- your story about having The Boxer playing on a loop while at the lake resonated with me but I just couldn't pull the trigger here, my man. Great song though!
But this is just a flat-out fun little tune. I love the raw feeling of this one, it almost feels a cappella in a way. Just like a group of friends around a campfire singing about "making love in the afternoon to Cecilia / Up in my bedroom (making love!)." What scandalous lyrics for 1970! No real story here, other than everyone needs a little S&G on their list and this one does not disappoint!
Other Songs Considered:
Mrs. Robinson, The Boxer, I Am a Rock